Plans to build around 700 homes in York have been recommended for approval, despite major opposition to the scheme.
Barratt and David Wilson Homes and the Vistry Group want outline permission to build the estate in Haxby.
It’s on land to the south of Rose Cottage Farm and The Lodge on Moor Lane.
Open space, informal sports pitches, allotments and play spaces, along with a 50-place early years nursery, are included in the plans.
It has been reduced from an original proposal of 800 homes. A plan to build a primary school has also been dropped.
Thirty per cent of homes would be affordable. There would also be specialist accommodation for older people.
Thirty-five self build plots and three gypsy and traveller pitches are part of the proposal.
The site is currently farmland, and previously in the green belt. But in York’s new local plan it is earmarked for citywide housing developments.
Among those objecting is the York Civic Trust, which said it would have an adverse impact on traffic with a lack of public transport provision.
A total of 339 letters of objection were sent in by residents. They raised issues including:
- health services in the area are already at capacity
- pressure on local schools
- the open space planned is inadequate
- too much extra traffic for already congested roads
- detrimental impact on wildlife and ecology.
Six letters of support for the scheme were received, some pointing out York’s desperate need for homes.

In a report to councillors, officers recommend they grant planning permission, saying: “Overall, and on balance, it is demonstrated that the proposal would achieve sustainable development in providing housing, supporting strong and healthy communities whilst making efficient use of land and enhancing the natural environment.”
A spokesperson for Barratt and David Wilson Homes, and Vistry Group said: “We are pleased that our proposal in Haxby for much-needed new homes, including 30% affordable, a children’s nursey, and extensive open green space, is recommended for approval by planning officers.
“We have engaged extensively with the local community, stakeholders, and officers over a long period to refine the scheme and agree significant financial contributions to local priorities.
“This has included discussions on key matters such as highways, healthcare, education and scheme design to bring us to a positive recommendation. Land North of Haxby is a key strategic element of York’s adopted Local Plan.”
The plan will be discussed at a meeting of the planning committee next Thursday (19 June).